A great pet stocking has a little of everything: one toy to play with, one thing to work for, a small treat and something useful. Pick each item to fit your pet’s age, size, chewing style and play style, and leave out anything with string, ribbon or small parts.
Table of Contents
ToggleThis guide has separate cat and dog sections, plus a simple table to help you build a balanced stocking. For bigger presents, see our cat holiday gift guide and best Christmas gifts for dogs.
Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Kritter Kommunity earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
How do you build a balanced pet stocking?
Think of a pet stocking like a small, balanced meal of fun. One item from each row below is plenty.
| Stocking slot | For a cat | For a dog | Why it belongs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Play | Catnip mice or crinkle balls | A rubber ball sized for your dog | Burns energy and builds your bond |
| Brain work | A kicker toy or food-hunting toy | A stuffable rubber toy or snuffle mat | Keeps pets busy and curious |
| Treat | A lickable treat or dental treat | Small training treats | A little holiday joy |
| Care | A slicker brush | Paw wax for winter walks | Useful long after Christmas |
| For you | A lint roller for cat hair | A poop bag holder | Makes daily pet life easier |
Keep treats small. WSAVA says treats should make up less than 10% of a dog’s daily calories, and its cat treat guide gives the same limit for cats.
What should you put in a cat’s Christmas stocking?

Cats love small toys they can bat, chase and carry. Choose toys that match how your cat likes to hunt.
Toys for chasing and pouncing
- SmartyKat Skitter Critters catnip mice: Light, soft mice for batting around the house.
- SunGrow crinkle balls: Crinkly, lightweight balls many cats love to chase.
A toy that keeps your cat busy
- Catstages Crunchy Pickle kicker: A long catnip toy for grabbing and bunny-kicking.
A treat
- Inaba Churu lickable treats: A creamy, squeezable treat you can share by hand. See our roundup of the best lickable cat treats.
- Greenies Feline dental treats: Crunchy treats in a cat-friendly size.
A grooming tool
- Coastal Pet Safari self-cleaning slicker brush: A cat-sized slicker brush with a button that pushes out loose fur.
Which cat stocking stuffers suit kittens, adults and seniors?
Kittens need small, light toys and lots of short play sessions. Mice and crinkle balls are perfect, as long as you check them often for damage.
Adult cats who love to hunt do best with a mix of chase toys and a kicker. If your cat ignores toys, try a different “prey” type, like a feather instead of a mouse.
Senior cats may prefer gentle play and comfort. A soft brush and a lickable treat can be the highlight of their morning.
Which cat toys should stay out of the stocking?
Skip toys with long string, yarn or loose ribbon unless they’re wand toys you put away after supervised play. Ohio State’s Indoor Pet Initiative warns that cats can bite or chew off pieces of string toys.
Don’t decorate the stocking with ribbon or tinsel either. Pet Poison Helpline recommends keeping tinsel, ribbon, yarn and thread away from pets.
What should you put in a dog’s Christmas stocking?

Dogs love stockings with something to chew, chase and sniff out. The trick is choosing the right size and toughness for your dog.
Toys for chewing and fetching
- KONG Classic: A stuffable rubber toy that comes in sizes for most dogs.
- Chuckit! Ultra Ball: A bouncy rubber fetch ball that floats.
- KONG Wubba Puppy: A floppy tug-and-toss toy sized for puppies.
Brain work
- AWOOF snuffle mat: Hide kibble in the fabric strips and let your dog sniff it out.
A treat
- Zuke’s Mini Naturals: Small soft treats that are easy to break up for training games.
Care items
- Musher’s Secret paw wax: A paw wax for winter walks on snow and salted sidewalks.
- Earth Rated poop bag holder: A leash dispenser with 15 bags, a gift for the human on walks.
For more cold-weather ideas, see our winter dog essentials.
How do you pick stocking stuffers for your dog’s size and chewing style?
Size up when in doubt. Humane World for Animals warns that toys that are too small can be swallowed or lodge in the throat.
Chewing style matters as much as size. Gentle carriers can enjoy plush toys, but power chewers do better with tough rubber toys like KONG.
Puppies need softer, teething-friendly toys. Senior dogs often enjoy calm brain games, like a snuffle mat, more than rough play.
| Your dog | Good stocking choices | Skip |
|---|---|---|
| Puppy | KONG Puppy, Wubba Puppy, small training treats | Hard chews and adult-size treats |
| Gentle carrier | Plush toys without hard eyes, snuffle mat | Toys with loose ribbons |
| Power chewer | KONG Classic or Extreme, sized up | Plush and stuffed toys |
| Fetch fan | Chuckit! Ultra Ball | Small balls they could swallow |
| Senior | Snuffle mat, soft treats, paw wax | High-impact games |
How many treats can go in a pet’s stocking?
Keep it to one small bag of treats, and hand them out over several days. WSAVA says treats should always make up less than 10% of a pet’s daily calories.
That’s a small amount for small pets. WSAVA’s dog treat guide lists a 10 kg (22 lb) dog at about 47 treat calories a day, and its cat treat guide lists a 4 kg (8.8 lb) cat at about 22.
Use treats made for pets, not people food. The AVMA warns that chocolate is toxic to dogs and cats and that sweets may contain xylitol.
Which dog stocking stuffers should you avoid?
Avoid toys with small parts, loose strings or hard plastic eyes. Humane World for Animals notes that these are pieces dogs can chew off and swallow.
Skip cooked bones as stocking treats. WSAVA warns that cooked and raw bones can cause significant damage if chewed or swallowed.
Take the stocking down once the gifts are opened. A stocking full of treats is a big temptation for a dog home alone.
Should you buy a stocking made just for your pet?
A pet stocking makes the tradition feel official, and it’s easy to hang up out of reach. A personalized pet stocking with your pet’s name is a sweet keepsake you can reuse every year.
Hang the stocking where pets can’t pull it down, and keep it away from
How do you keep stocking time safe and fun?
Open the stocking with your pet when the house is calm. Remove all tags, plastic and packaging before you hand anything over.
Throw away wrapping and ribbon right away. The AVMA warns that ribbons and similar decorations can cause choking or intestinal blockage if swallowed.
Supervise new toys for the first few play sessions. For more tree-time tips, see our guide to cat-proofing a Christmas tree and our holiday safety tips for cat owners.
Can you make your own pet stocking stuffers?
Yes, and homemade gifts can be just as loved. A simple homemade gift, like a fleece tug toy for a dog or a cozy box bed for a cat, can mean just as much as something store-bought. Our DIY Christmas gifts for cats and dogs show you how.
You can also bake a batch of pet treats from a trusted recipe. Try our Christmas dog treat recipe or festive cat treat recipe, and share them a few at a time.
Shopping for the humans too? Our pet lover gift ideas cover ornaments, keepsakes and funny gifts for pet people.
Save this guide to Pinterest
Choose your favorite design.








